Paycheck to HELOC
A HELOC that replaces your mortgage (a first-lien HELOC) can be a strong tool. Run your real month through it, every paycheck in and every bill out, to see if it costs less than the mortgage you have.
1 · Your mortgage
The principal balance on your statement.
From your statement. The starting figures are examples, not a quote or an offer.
360 months. Principal and interest: $1,995.91 a month.
2 · The HELOC
From a lender's written disclosure. An assumption you enter, not a quote.
From the lender's disclosure. Added to what you owe on day one.
Title, appraisal, recording.
3 · Your month
Money coming in
Bills and spending (leave your mortgage payment out)
Paid once or twice a year
Property taxes and home insurance go here, even when they are collected with your mortgage payment (escrow).
Everything left over goes to the house on both sides, so add what you save or spend elsewhere as a bill. These lists are never emailed.
Your mortgage, paying $4,500 a month
Paid off in 7.1 yrs
$81,020 interest
That is the number to beat. Enter a HELOC rate in step 2 to run the same month through the HELOC.
Illustration from your inputs: not a quote, an offer or an approval.
Your first month on the HELOC
Enter a HELOC rate in step 2 to see your month on the HELOC.
This is a modeled cash-flow strategy: not every HELOC works like a checking account.
A HELOC is secured by your home
- It's secured by your home. Falling behind on the payments can put the house at risk.
- Most HELOCs have variable rates that can rise, up to the maximum in the agreement.
- A lender can stop new draws or lower your limit in limited cases, including a significant drop in your home's value, missed payments, or a material change in your finances that leads the lender to believe you can't repay.
- You can redraw only during the draw period in the agreement.
- Most HELOCs have no escrow account. You pay property taxes and insurance yourself when they are due, and missing them can put the house at risk.
To payoff, month by month
How this is figured
- Loan figures are principal and interest only. Property taxes, home insurance and HOA dues count only where you list them in your month: yearly ones under “Paid once or twice a year”, monthly ones as bills.
- If your mortgage payment includes mortgage insurance, leave it out of your bills: it isn't counted on either side, and because it ends when the HELOC pays off your mortgage, the HELOC compares better than shown here.
- Your mortgage charges interest monthly, at the rate divided by 12, and is paid at month end.
- The HELOC charges simple interest daily, at the rate divided by 360 on 30-day months, added monthly. A lender that uses a 360-day year on actual calendar days charges a bit more.
- Every month in the model has 30 days, and every month repeats the one you entered. A bill due on the 31st runs on day 30.
- Income lands on the days you enter. Pay every two weeks is averaged to a month: 26 paychecks a year, half on day 1 and half on day 15. Weekly pay is averaged the same way: 52 a year, a quarter on each of days 1, 8, 15 and 22.
- Within a day, deposits land first, then that day's bills are paid, then that day's share of everyday spending is drawn, then the day's interest is figured on the balance that's left.
- Everyday spending (the items set to a little every day) is drawn evenly, one thirtieth each day. With the card on, it's charged to a card and paid in full from the HELOC on day 25 of the next month.
- The model starts the day after this year's yearly bills were paid. A bill paid once a year first comes due at the end of month 12; a bill paid twice a year, at the end of months 6 and 12.
- On your mortgage, the money for yearly bills is set aside every month, in an escrow account or in your own account. On the HELOC it stays against what you owe until each bill is due.
- The HELOC counts as paid off when what you owe on it, plus the money set aside for yearly bills (and the card, when it's on), reaches zero.
- The answer's line about your yearly bills gives the HELOC's interest to payoff if the same yearly money left it every month (a twelfth on day 30), minus its interest as run here.
- On the mortgage side, everything left over at month end goes to the mortgage: the required payment first, the rest to principal.
- On the mortgage side, money waiting in checking between paydays earns nothing. If your account pays interest, the HELOC compares worse than shown here.
- Fees and closing costs are added to the starting balance.
- Rates stay the same for the whole payoff except in the rate-rise check.
- Both sides, and all three checks, send the same monthly total to the house.
- Payoff is measured the same way on both sides: at month end. A last month that uses only part of the monthly total counts as part of a month, and the answer rounds the count to the nearest month. The month-by-month lists show every month a payment is made.
- The HELOC rate is an assumption you enter, not a quote.
- There's no eligibility check: this doesn't look at credit, income, the home's value or lender rules.
- Total cost is interest plus the upfront fee and costs. Dollar figures in the comparison are rounded so they add up on the screen, so a figure can be a dollar or two off its exact amount.
- A HELOC has its own minimum payment, set by the agreement. This model assumes the money you deposit covers it.
Email me this analysis
The Mortgage Payoff Experiment
The series behind this calculator. We test mortgage strategies, run the numbers, and show homeowners what actually works, including the cases where the answer is “keep the mortgage you have.”
About the seriesA HELOC behind your first mortgage
Keeping your first mortgage and adding a HELOC or a home equity loan behind it is a different setup from the one above. That calculator compares those two, including the payment after the draw period ends.
HELOC vs. home equity loanThis calculator is educational. It is not a loan offer, a rate quote, an approval or a commitment to lend. Rates, fees and terms vary by lender, credit, property and state. Every figure is an estimate, and most HELOCs have variable rates. Not tax or legal advice. David Lurvey, NMLS 410420. Equal Housing Opportunity.